Skeptic's Response to Margaret Mead
In 1983 the famed anthropologist Margaret
Mead came under attack by those skeptical of her theories of Cultural
Anthropology. She had caused a great controversy in the scientific
and academic communities with her endorsement of the new science
of parapsychology. By 1983 her ideas on anthropology were under
critical fire and her reputation as one of the world's greatest
anthropologists began to decline. The primary cause of the decline
of Mead's reputation was Margaret Mead and Somoa: The
Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth, by Derek
Freeman of the Australian National University. Freeman claimed
that Mead's famous Coming of Age in Somoa gave a distorted picture
of the behavioral standards governing sexuality in Somoan society
in order to support the idea that cultural and not biological
factors are the most important determents of human behavior. Margaret
Mead said that the repression, fear and guilt she considered to
be endemic in industrial society were not reflected in Somoan
attitudes or behavior, and she argued that attitudes toward sexuality
and other profound human emotions must therefore be shaped by
culture and circumstance, not by biology or genetic endowment.
Her critic, Freeman, insisted that her basic conclusions, and
the findings on which she based them, were wrong.
By the 1990s Freeman's analysis had gone from the front page
of the New York Times into magazine articles. In 1998
the controversy comes to the World Wide Web.
|
|